You hit a pothole on a Kingston road. Your tyre blows out. Your alloy cracks. Or worse — you come off your bike and end up in A&E. What happens next? Can you actually claim compensation from Kingston Council, and what are your chances of success?
The honest answer: it is possible, but the council has a legal shield most residents do not know about. Here is exactly how the process works, what evidence you need, and what you can realistically expect.
Before you start drafting a claim, understand the legal landscape. Kingston Council — like every highway authority in England — is protected by Section 58 of the Highways Act 1980. This means it can avoid liability if it proves it had a reasonable system of inspection and maintenance in place, and that it could not reasonably have known about the defect in time to fix it.
In plain English: the council does not have to maintain perfect roads. It has to maintain a reasonable programme of inspections and repairs. If a pothole opened up yesterday and you drove over it this morning, the council will almost certainly escape liability.
This is the single most important thing to understand before you invest time in a claim.
The moment you are safe to do so, report the pothole through Kingston Council's online portal at kingston.gov.uk/report-it. Do this even if the damage has already happened. Your report creates a timestamped record that the council was put on notice.
Keep a screenshot of the confirmation email or reference number. This becomes part of your evidence pack.
Also check whether the pothole was already on the council's system. Kingston uses a public-facing map of reported defects. If someone else reported it days or weeks before your incident — and the council failed to act — that significantly strengthens your case.
If you are physically able to do so safely, collect the following before you leave:
If you have suffered a personal injury, seek medical attention straight away and ask for a written record of your injuries and treatment. A medical report will be central to any personal injury claim.
Get a written repair estimate or invoice from a reputable garage. Keep all receipts. If you needed a hire car while yours was being repaired, keep those receipts too.
For personal injury, keep records of any lost earnings, travel costs to medical appointments, and any prescription charges related to the incident.
Do not exaggerate. Claims that look inflated are easier for insurers and councils to challenge, and it undermines your credibility on the legitimate losses.
Write formally to Kingston Council's Highway Claims team at Kingston upon Thames, Guildhall 2, Kingston upon Thames, KT1 1EU, or via the claims portal on the council website.
Your letter or form should include:
Keep a copy of everything you send. If posting, use recorded delivery.
Once your claim is received, Kingston Council will acknowledge it and begin an investigation. The council's standard practice is to respond within 10 working days, though complex claims may take longer.
During this window, the council will:
This is where the Section 58 defence becomes real. If the council can show the road was inspected recently and the pothole was not present — or was below the actionable threshold — it will likely reject your claim.
If the council's records show the pothole was known about and a repair had been scheduled but not yet completed, you are in stronger territory.
Kingston Council's Highway Maintenance Policy sets out inspection frequencies by road category. A-roads and busy residential streets are inspected more frequently than quiet back roads. The council is judged against its own published standards.
If an inspector passed a road two days before your incident and noted no defect — but the pothole was clearly large enough to have been developing for weeks — you can challenge that inspection record. This is where professional legal advice becomes worthwhile for higher-value claims.
For claims above roughly £1,000, consider consulting a solicitor who handles highway claims. Many offer a free initial consultation. For smaller claims, the small claims track in the county court (up to £10,000) allows you to represent yourself without needing a lawyer.
Be honest with yourself about the odds. The council rejects a significant proportion of pothole claims by relying on the Section 58 defence. Claims succeed most often when:
If your claim is rejected and you believe it is wrongly so, you can escalate to the Local Government Ombudsman (now the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman) if you feel the council's process was flawed — though the Ombudsman cannot award compensation for road damage directly, it can investigate maladministration.
For contested financial claims, the county court small claims track is your route. Filing fees start from £35 for claims under £300.
It is worth noting that Kingston residents are paying £2,608.12 a year in Band D council tax for 2026/27 — a rise of £119.77 on the previous year. The council is also facing a projected £18 million budget gap over the next four years against reserves of just £14.2 million.
That financial pressure has consequences for road maintenance budgets. When money is tight, pothole repair programmes are often among the first to see cuts or delays. That is a question worth putting directly to your councillors: what is the current highways maintenance budget, and how has it changed?
Kingston has 48 councillors across 19 wards. They are accountable to you. If your street has a pothole problem, or if you feel the council is systematically failing its maintenance duties, your councillor needs to hear it.
Use Council Clarity to message your Kingston councillors directly. It takes two minutes, it creates a written record, and it puts the issue on their radar before the next full council elections on 7 May 2026. Don't wait for the next blowout — ask now what Kingston Council's highways maintenance budget is, how many pothole claims were paid out last year, and how many were rejected.
Share this post
Want to have your say on this issue?
Contact your local councillor through Council Clarity. Your message becomes a public thread.
Message your councillor →Kingston now has London's highest Band D council tax at £2,608.12. Here's every discount and reduction scheme residents can claim — and how to apply.
explainerKingston's Regulation 19 Local Plan sets every planning rule until 2041. Here's what it means, what's controversial, and how to have your say before the deadline.
explainerGot a parking ticket in Kingston? Here's exactly how to challenge it — from the 14-day discount window to the independent Traffic Penalty Tribunal.